Gender Self Identification

Syllabus- General Studies 2 (polity)

Issues relating to quality of life: livelihood, poverty, hunger, disease and social inclusiveness.

Context

The Spanish government recently approved the first draft of a bill that would allow anyone over the age of 14 to legally change gender without a medical diagnosis or hormone therapy.

Furthermore:

• Currently, for someone to change their gender in official records, the law first requires two years of hormone therapy and a psychological evaluation.
• The proposed law will remove these requirements for everyone above 14 years of age. Those between 14 and 16, however, would require parental approval.

What is gender self-identification?

Self-identification, or ‘self-id’, is the concept that a person should be allowed to legally identify with the gender of their choice by simply declaring so, and without facing any medical tests. This has been a long held demand of trans-right groups around the world, including in India, as prejudice against trans people remains rampant.

Issues

• In Europe, this issue has remained divisive not only on liberal-conservative lines, but also within the LGBT community
• While some believe that the current processes for declaring one’s desired gender are lengthy, expensive and degrading, some feminist and gay-rights groups insist that such a law could endanger women and cause more gay teenagers to be told that they might be trans and thus encouraged towards hormones and surgery.
• Feminist forums that believe that sex is not something which can be chosen have insisted that allowing self-identification could put at risk all laws that specifically prevent discrimination against women, and have instead asked lawmakers to look at concerns that they say are more pressing, such as the gender pay gap.

Legality of Self-ID across the world

As per the advocacy group ILGA (the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association), 15 countries around the world recognise self-ID, including Denmark, Portugal, Norway, Malta, Argentina, Ireland, Luxembourg, Greece, Costa Rica, Mexico (only in Mexico City), Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador and Uruguay.

• In Denmark, the law requires a six-month reflection period for formalising gender change.
• In Portugal, changing one’s gender for the second time requires going to court.
• Italy does not allow self-ID, and neither does Germany, where last month a bill was voted down that would have legalised gender-reassignment surgery from the age of 14 regardless of opposition from parents, as well as introduced a fine of 2,500 euros for referring to a trans person based on their natal sex.
• In Hungary, a newly adopted law effectively bans all content about homosexuality and gender change from school curriculum and television shows for children under the age of 18.

Process for self identification in India

• In India, the rights of transgender persons are governed by the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 and the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Rules, 2020.
• Under the Rules, an application to declare gender is to be made to the District Magistrate. Parents can also make an application on behalf of their child.
• A much-criticised previous draft of regulations required transgender persons to go through a medical examination for declaring their desired sex.
• This requirement was omitted in the final Rules, which state that the District Magistrate will subject to the correctness of the applicant’s particulars, get the application processed based on the affidavit submitted declaring:
  • The gender identity of any person, without any medical or physical examination, and
  • Thereafter, issue an identification number to the applicant, which may be quoted as proof of application.
• As per the Rules, state governments have also been directed to constitute welfare boards for transgender persons to protect their rights and interests, and facilitate access to schemes and welfare measures framed by the Centre.

Question- Right to self identification of gender is necessary to for ensuring social justice to the LBGT community. Comment .

Article- https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/gender-self-identification-law-india-7383108/